PolitiFact22%
Diarrhea parasites, glass in bread: Is our food getting less safe? What experts told us 26%
By Madison Czopek27%
8/4/2026, 8:49:18 AM
Keywords: Food Safety, Cyclosporiasis, Outbreaks, Foodborne Illness, Recalls, Trump Administration, Fda, Usda, Cdc
BS Summary: This article contains 27 faulty reasoning types, including Appeal to Authority, Hasty Generalization, and Post Hoc (False Cause), with Negativity Bias as the most egregious example at 20.3% saturation with 252 hits. Analysis detected 1,850 faulty-reasoning hits from 1,244 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 31.5% and a BS Rank of 26% (21,419 of 28,846 articles). This article is better (less manipulative) than 74.30% of the article peer group.
The eggs are contaminated with salmonella.
Frozen berries have been linked to an E. coli outbreak.
Iceberg lettuce and who knows what else might give you explosive diarrhea.
Some people have endured the barrage of frightening food news with dark humor.
“So the bread has glass in it, the lettuce has diarrhea bacteria, the eggs have salmonella,” wrote one Facebook user, poking at recalls of Pillsbury bread rolls for possible glass contamination and iceberg lettuce for cyclospora contamination.
“At this point, grocery shopping is just an overpriced episode of Fear Factor.”
Jokes about U.S. food safety concerns are plentiful across social media.
(Screenshots from X, Facebook and Threads)
The jokes can be funny , but the unanswered question behind them is not: Is our food becoming less safe?
The U.S. food supply is “among the safest in the world,” said Steven Mandernach, the Association of Food and Drug Officials’ executive director.
“It’s always been among the safest in the world.
I see nothing that has changed.”
But it’s notoriously difficult to answer in real-time whether our food is getting less safe, food safety experts said.
Most expect the Trump administration’s cuts to federal, state and local public health entities to weaken the nation’s food safety guardrails in the long run.
Whether that is playing out in the short term is less clear.
Here’s what else we learned from food safety experts, and diving into the data.
The cyclosporiasis situation doesn’t prove food safety is rapidly declining.
Yes, record-breaking numbers of domestically obtained cyclosporiasis cases recorded in 45 states have heightened food safety concerns.
But cyclosporiasis outbreaks are difficult to catch quickly and the time it took for public health officials to identify a link between at least one product and the summer’s rising cyclosporiasis cases was “right on schedule with what we’ve seen with other cyclospora outbreaks,” Mandernach said.
“If anything, maybe a tiny bit earlier than normal.”
That suggests the U.S. surveillance system is working, he said.
Plus, previous cyclosporiasis outbreaks were likely undercounted, he said, because testing accuracy has improved in the past five years.
Cyclosporiasis outbreaks vary from year to year, but during some seasons, multiple failures cause big outbreaks, said Don Schaffner, a Rutgers University food science specialist.
“I don’t know that we have a perfect storm this year, but hopefully we will learn something more about why this particular outbreak was so bad,” he said July 22.
Mandernach said this year’s uptick does signal that the U.S. hasn’t invested enough in cyclospora research and prevention in the past two decades.
But it’s not a sign that food is getting less safe.
However, if health officials never determine what went wrong to cause this record-breaking cyclosporiasis season, that could be cause for concern, he said.
U.S. officials linked lettuce from one company to cyclosporiasis.
But rising cases are the result of multiple outbreaks, and not all of them have been traced to a source.
(Shutterstock)
Summer is when foodborne illness is more common and gets more media attention.
More foodborne illnesses happen in summer.
“It’s hot,” Mandernach said.
“Refrigeration sometimes fails.”
It’s also when pathogens like cyclospora and salmonella are most common.
Increased news coverage makes people pay closer attention to food safety issues and notice subsequent headlines about other recalls for pathogens or other contaminants.
What does data show about food recalls and illness outbreaks?
To really know if food is becoming less safe, it’s important to analyze cases of foodborne illness.
Yet getting complete and current data is difficult.
Historically, the best data on foodborne disease trends came from the FoodNet program, a collaboration between the U.S.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the U.S.
Food and Drug Administration, the U.S.
Department of Agriculture and 10 state health departments.
Its most recent data is from 2024, and it showed that the incidence of infections acquired in the U.S. were rising for shigella, Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (STEC), Vibrio and Yersinia.
For years, FoodNet participants reported data on eight pathogens including cyclospora, but in July 2025, the Trump administration made it optional to report data for cyclospora and five other pathogens.
Based on the data made public about the FDA’s Coordinated Outbreak Response & Evaluation Response (CORE) Teams’ investigations into foodborne outbreaks, we’re seeing slightly more outbreak investigations this year than before.
So far in 2026, the FDA has posted approximately 2.71 investigations each month.
In the first seven months of 2025, the FDA posted 2.29 investigations per month.
In 2024, it was 1.43 per month; 1.86 per month in 2023; and 2.29 in 2022.
This data doesn’t include all investigations into outbreaks.
It includes many multistate outbreak investigations that were assigned to a CORE team, but that’s a relatively small proportion of the total outbreaks that occur, said Rutgers University epidemiologist Craig Hedberg.
Available food and beverage recall data from the FDA and shows the number of recalls in 2026 is on pace with recent years — at least so far.
Data from the USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service shows that in 2025, the U.S. recorded a 10-year high total of pounds of recalled meat, poultry and egg products.
From 2015 to 2025, Food Safety and Inspection Services reported that manufacturers recalled an average of about 23.2 million pounds of meat, poultry and egg products.
The USDA website’s recall data shows that in 2026, manufacturers have already recalled over 37 million pounds of these products.
Even combined, this data doesn’t tell a comprehensive food safety story.
It’s overly simplistic to view increasing outbreak investigations or recalls as proof that the system is getting worse.
Upticks in investigations and recalls “could be a sign that more issues are being caught,” said Sarah Sorscher, the Center for Science in the Public Interest’s director of regulatory affairs.
Trump administration policies could weaken food safety standards, experts warn
Some food safety experts say the administration’s cuts have hindered the government’s response and communication to the cyclosporiasis outbreaks, but Mandernach is among those who disagree.
Mandernach said the cyclospora response played out as he would expect, suggesting the cuts had “very limited, if any impact.”
The cyclospora situation aside, other impacts are clear.
In 2025, American inspections of foreign food facilities dropped to historic lows because of the cuts, Sorscher said.
The administration has also deprioritized criminal enforcement for violating regulations, which might mean companies are less motivated to comply.
She pointed to a stalled Boar’s Head investigation and the halted prosecution of Abbott Nutrition as examples.
An aerial view of the Boar’s Head processing plant that was tied to a deadly food poisoning outbreak Aug. 29, 2024, in Jarratt, Va.
(AP)
Future food safety is also uncertain, experts warned.
Scaling back FoodNet’s pathogen surveillance will undermine future efforts to monitor trends in foodborne illness, Hedberg said.
Sorscher said the FDA, CDC and state and local public health agencies are losing qualified experts to early retirement and struggling to maintain qualified staff to inspect food and solve outbreaks.
“FDA and USDA have also dissolved advisory committees and de-prioritized enforcement and regulation,” she said.
“Long term, this will have an impact on the safety of food as standards deteriorate.”
PolitiFact Staff Researcher Caryn Baird and PolitiFact Assistant Managing Editor Rebecca Catalanello contributed to this report.
RELATED: Sorting through the mixed messages on cyclosporiasis
RELATED: What is cyclosporiasis and how can you avoid catching this, uh, ‘explosive’ GI illness?
Speakers
4speakers36%attributed speech790writer words
Selected voice
92%flagged-word coverageSteven Mandernach
206 attributed words45% of attributed speech65% writer coverage
Attribution is sentence-level. Pattern percentages are calculated only from words assigned to that voice.
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.