The Lens50%
‘Music From the Big House’ delivers blues and soul from Angola prison 32%
By Maurice Chammah37% The Marshall Project24%
7/31/2026, 10:51:32 AM
BS Summary: This article contains 25 faulty reasoning types, including Negativity Bias, Framing Effect, and Availability Heuristic, with Appeal to Emotion as the most egregious example at 28.3% saturation with 276 hits. Analysis detected 1,824 faulty-reasoning hits from 974 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 35.4% and a BS Rank of 32% (18,282 of 26,788 articles). This article is better (less manipulative) than 68.20% of the article peer group.
Many years ago, at Louisiana State Penitentiary — better known as Angola Prison — I met a man who made ukuleles.
He showed me how he had crushed legal documents into a kind of particle board and twisted trash bags into strings.
His name is Wayne Guidry, and I saw him again in the 2010 documentary, “Music from the Big House,” in which he briefly meets the Canadian blues singer Rita Chiarelli and tells her about how music helps him deal with his shame and despair.
Guidry is serving a life sentence for killing a woman he was dating in 2003.
“Sometimes I just sit at the piano and cry it out,” he tells Chiarelli, “but also, if you were to observe it, you’d see the development of hope.”
Canadian blues singer Rita Chiarelli, center with guitar, performs with incarcerated musicians during the finale of a concert at the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola.
Chiarelli’s collaboration with the men is featured in the 2010 documentary “Music from the Big House,” which explores how music offered moments of connection, dignity and hope inside the prison.
(Photo courtesy of the production)
Chiarelli’s film is a great introduction to Angola, which is among the bleakest prisons in the country, but also home to a deep bench of ringers who play gospel, soul, and other genres in bands called Pure Heart Messenger, The Jazzmen and Little Country.
The level of musicianship isn’t surprising when you consider the prison has lots of men from New Orleans, the birthplace of jazz, and is not far from the Mississippi Delta, the birthplace of the blues.
Like Sonny James and Kirk Franklin, Chiarelli didn’t just go into a prison to put on a show and get good PR for her own career.
She helped the men put on a show for each other.
When you hear her lead them in “The Midnight Special,” our selection for this week, it feels like you’re eavesdropping on the great time they’re having.
The film makes it clear how rare these good times are.
“When you’re playing music it’s easy to forget where you are,” Chiarelli says to the camera, “but they’re still in prison, and it’s rough.”
She visits cramped, dirty dorms where men have heartbreaking looks on their faces during mail call.
Most of the men at Angola are serving life sentences and will die there.
“Part of me says, ‘There’s victims too,’ and you have to remember that,” Chiarelli says in the film.
“And then on the other hand there’s these guys who made one mistake… and it’s a real tear in my fiber, how to feel about all of this.”
July 1932, prison compound no.
1, Angola, Louisiana.
Leadbelly (Huddie Ledbetter) in the foreground.
(Photo courtesy of Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division.)
Built on a former plantation, Angola is a longstanding symbol of American punitiveness, where men still do farm labor in the heat amid armed guards on horseback, when they’re not held for decades in solitary confinement.
Recently, members of the Trump administration stood outside to announce that a wing at Angola, once known as “the dungeon,” would be used to house people detained by ICE.
But amid the decades of horror stories, music has always trickled out.
At the Smithsonian’s website, you can hear a lot of blues and spirituals recorded by an academic named Harry Oster in the 1950s.
Chiarelli’s choice to cover “The Midnight Special” with the men inside pays homage to how the song’s history is deeply enmeshed with Angola.
Huddie Ledbetter, also known as Lead Belly, in 1948.
“Midnight Special” was one of his signature songs.
The song’s lyrics are all about hoping a lover will arrive on a late-night train to deliver the singer to freedom.
It’s an old folk song, but it remains famous because of the version recorded at Angola in the 1930s by the blues singer known as Lead Belly.
(The song did not, as one myth has it, help him get out of prison.)
Chiarelli got in with a film crew during the tenure of Warden Burl Cain.
From 1993 to 2016, he became one of America’s most famous wardens, in part because he let in so many cameras and often appeared at the prison’s annual rodeo.
Cain oversaw a drop in violence, which he credited to new ministry programs.
But he also faced plenty of abuse accusations, particularly for those who refused to be politically quiet or adopt his brand of evangelical Christianity.
Court records reviewed by The New Yorker suggest he was particularly punitive towards members of the Black Panther Party.
Since Cain left, most of the administration-sanctioned music seems to be concerts by visiting Christian worship bands.
We can only hope more scholars and performers like Chiarelli can secure access so we can hear more of the music being made by the Angola men themselves.
Music has long offered incarcerated men at the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola a source of expression and hope.
From left, Albert Patterson, featured on the song “Harvest,” and Ray Jones, were among the incarcerated musicians who sang on the recording with Rita Chiarelli (Photo courtesy of the production)
I still haven’t found a recording of Guidry’s ukuleles, but I remember the quiet plunk of the trash bag strings.
When I met him, he told me he’d play them at night when others were sleeping.
What came through to me in Chiarelli’s movie is that these guys aren’t asking to be forgiven by society for their crimes, much less adored as musical stars.
They’re asking for a sliver of hope, and there’s no better metaphor than the single headlight of a train in the distance.
Maurice Chammah writes about the death penalty, forensics, and art and music behind bars.
Speakers
4speakers15%attributed speech828writer words
Selected voice
100%flagged-word coverageWayne Guidry
28 attributed words19% of attributed speech83% writer coverage
Attribution is sentence-level. Pattern percentages are calculated only from words assigned to that voice.
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.