MS NOW95%
GOP member becomes an independent, narrowing House Republicans’ edge again74%
By Steve Benen98%
3/9/2026, 8:05:28 PM
Topics: Maddowblog
BS Summary: This article contains 19 faulty reasoning types, including Negativity Bias, Self-Serving Bias, and Pessimism Bias, with Framing Effect as the most egregious example at 56.1% saturation with 314 hits. Analysis detected 1,280 faulty-reasoning hits from 561 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 66.9% and a BS Rank of 74% (4,423 of 16,813 articles). This article is worse (more manipulative) than 73.70% of the article peer group.
In the House, independent members are quite rare.
In fact, in recent years, there are only two examples: former Rep. Paul Mitchell of Michigan, who left the Republican Party to become an independent in 2020, and former Rep. Justin Amash, another former Michigan Republican who became a Libertarian the same year.
This rarefied company now numbers three.
The Hill reported:
Rep. Kevin Kiley (Calif.) announced Monday that he will formally leave the Republican Party this week to become an independent.
‘I will be the sole independent member of the House of Representatives,’ Kiley told reporters Monday during a virtual press conference.
Kiley had already indicated that he intended to run for re-election as an independent, instead of a GOP incumbent, though there have still been questions as to his party affiliation between now and Election Day.
The California congressman took steps to answer that question on Monday afternoon, telling reporters that he’s filing the paperwork with the House Clerk’s Office to identify as an independent, effective immediately, for the remainder of the current Congress.
As an electoral strategy, Kiley very likely realized that his options were limited: Under the state’s new congressional district map, designed to give Democrats a significant boost, his district will become vastly more difficult for a Republican to win.
Abandoning the GOP might give the incumbent lawmaker a better chance of keeping his seat.
But while Kiley scrambles to save his career after voting for some very conservative legislation, including the Republican Party’s domestic policy megabill last summer (the inaptly named One Big Beautiful Bill Act), there’s the broader context of Capitol Hill to consider.
As of New Year’s Day 2026, the House Republican Conference had 220 members, giving the GOP a narrow advantage over the Democratic minority.
The Republican total dropped to 219 soon after, as then-Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia resigned (right after she became eligible for a congressional pension).
One day later, the GOP advantage fell again, when Republican Rep. Doug LaMalfa of California died unexpectedly.
Then Democratic Rep. Christian Menefee of Texas won a special election and was sworn in, further narrowing the gap between the parties in the chamber.
At that point, the GOP had 218 House members to the Democrats’ 214, which, as a matter of legislative arithmetic, meant Republican leaders could only afford to lose one vote in any major floor fight.
But with Kiley becoming an independent, the House Republican majority is now down to 217 votes — in a chamber where 218 is a majority.
To be sure, House Speaker Mike Johnson of Louisiana probably isn’t panicking, or at least not any more than usual, for the simple fact that Kiley has vowed to continue to caucus with the GOP (a necessary move to maintain his current committee assignments).
That said, Kiley will likely be looking for new ways to prove his independent bona fides in the coming weeks and months, which suggests Republican leaders shouldn’t count on his support.
What’s more, as more members retire or lose primary fights, attendance is likely to make matters even more difficult for GOP leaders hoping to pass anything meaningful between now and the midterm elections.
By any fair measure, 2025 was exceedingly difficult for Johnson and his party.
Every day seems to bring fresh reasons to believe 2026 will be worse.
This post updates our related earlier coverage.
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.