CBC News50%
Devastation in Dawson City, Yukon, as iconic hotel is razed by fire 6%
By Chris MacIntyre0% Hina Alam0% Caitrin Pilkington0%
5/17/2026, 5:10:13 PM
BS Summary: This article contains 25 faulty reasoning types, including Halo Effect, Hasty Generalization, and Loss Aversion, with Negativity Bias as the most egregious example at 20.6% saturation with 154 hits. Analysis detected 1,187 faulty-reasoning hits from 748 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 21.9% and a BS Rank of 6% (15,893 of 16,813 articles). This article is better (less manipulative) than 94.50% of the article peer group.
Dawson City, Yukon’s iconic tavern, the Westminster Hotel, aka “The Pit,” was destroyed in a fire on Sunday morning — just months after the bar survived a devastating flood.
Fire crews battled the blaze burning at the beloved Dawson City community landmark for hours.
But the building, which dated back to 1898, has now been razed.
Heavy smoke blanketed downtown, and fire crews asked residents to stay away from the building for their own safety.
Dawson City posted on social media at 9:26 a.m., saying firefighters were responding to "a significant structure fire" at the Westminster Hotel.
"Please respect emergency responders and give them room to work safely," the post said.
"Those sensitive to smoke may wish to remain indoors and limit outdoor activity while smoke conditions persist."
There were no "known reports of injuries or threats to neighboring buildings," the post said.
Buffalo Taylor, Dawson City Fire Department chief, said the cause of the fire was unknown.
“There will be an investigation later, right now we have no idea what started it,” Taylor said.
For many in Dawson City, The Pit was more than a bar.
It was the town’s de facto living room, a 125-year-old institution where locals gathered and marked life’s milestones.
Its loss, coming close on the heels of a severe flood that had already forced it to close, has left the community reeling.
Coun.
Cud Eastbound, who stood in front of the hotel as firefighters fought the blaze, said they felt “devastated."
They said a crowd had gathered in the area, and that they had arrived around 8 a.m.
“Everyone’s in shock,” they said.
“Crews are on site, suppressing what flames are left.
Large amount of community members are out supporting each other, giving each other hugs.”
There were gasps in the crowd as most of the structure collapsed.
“An iconic part of the town is gone now,” said Matthew Wright, another Dawson resident who was watching the scene unfold.
Shirley Paraluman said the “whole town is grieving" the destruction of the beloved icon.
“This is a piece of history.
This building is a history to everyone,” said Paraluman, who’s lived in Dawson for 17 years.
“I don’t want to cry but it’s just so sad, this [building] brought life to the whole town.”
While The Pit was closed at the time of the fire, many Yukoners were hopeful they could return to the beloved bar later this summer.
The Westminster Hotel began having problems early this year after city water mains broke during a deep freeze in early January.
The hotel had about one metre of water.
Josée Montreuil, manager of The Pit, said in an interview last week that it took about eight days for workers to get the water shut off in January after the hotel flooded.
“We got it below the floor from the first day, but the basement is still full right now because of water.
Now that the ground is thawing again, all of that other water is going back towards the building,” she said.
Montreuil said workers were already pumping water and getting dehumidifiers running in the building.
“Then we tear up the floor to redo the foundation.
So that's what's happening right now,” she said.
“We don't really have a timeline because it's construction in the Yukon, but we're hoping July for the Tavern.”
On Sunday morning, Dawson City Mayor Stephen Johnson watched as the pink building – that always stood out as a beacon for visitors, as well as a gathering place for the community – turned black with soot.
“We’ve lost an icon in this town,” he said.
“I’m just shocked.
It’s a huge loss.”
In a social media post on Sunday afternoon, Johnson said it was hard to put into words what the place meant to the town.
"The Westminster wasn’t just a bar or a hotel.
It was a gathering place, a landmark of stories, a home for music, laughter, friendship, and the kind of memories that only Dawson can make," he wrote.
The Westminster, he said, drew generations of Dawsonites through its doors — some as workers, others as regulars, and all of them at home.
"Losing it feels personal because it is personal."
The spirit of the place will live in the people who filled it, and the community will carry the stories forward, he added.
"When the time comes, we will help shape whatever rises next."
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.