Fox News88%
Americans turned Christmas dinner into patriotic duty during WWI with wartime recipes85%
By Deirdre Bardolf0%
12/20/2025, 4:00:00 PM
BS Summary: This article contains 12 faulty reasoning types, including Appeal to Authority, Appeal to Emotion, and Anecdotal, with Framing Effect as the most egregious example at 59.6% saturation with 459 hits. Analysis detected 1,513 faulty-reasoning hits from 770 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 78.3% and a BS Rank of 85% (2,539 of 16,813 articles). This article is worse (more manipulative) than 84.90% of the article peer group.
When Americans sat down to Christmas dinner in 1918, the meal wasn't just a celebration — it was an act of patriotism.
During World War I, the U.S. Food Administration urged households to save wheat, sugar, meat and fats so more food could be shipped to troops overseas — and it backed a cookbook, "Win the War in the Kitchen," filled with ration-friendly recipes.
Today, the National WWI Museum and Memorial in Kansas City preserves that cookbook through its online exhibit, "War Fare: From the Home Front to the Frontlines."
"Everyone must help if we are to win," the cookbook declared.
"Fats are the most precious thing in this war," it added, noting the Army needed them both to feed soldiers and produce glycerin for explosives.
Even sugar mattered: "Saving that ounce a day is part of YOUR WAR SERVICE."
The cookbook drew contributions from food companies, American Red Cross dietitians, women's auxiliaries and magazines of the era — with endorsements from figures like Herbert Hoover, then head of the U.S. Food Administration, and President Woodrow Wilson.
It was driven by patriotism, said Lora Vogt, the museum's vice president of education and interpretation.
Christmas still called for dishes that felt special.
"Hoover helped lead the nation, not by saying, 'The government is mandating this,' but instead, 'Each of you American families get the opportunity to support our nation and support American ideals by changing how you eat,'" Vogt told Fox News Digital.
While wartime substitutions like carrot coffee, soybean loaf and calls to "make every day a fish day" filled everyday meals, Christmas still called for dishes that felt special.
Below are seven dishes that would have appeared on some 1918 American Christmas tables.
1. Relish tray
Before charcuterie boards dominated social media, the centerpiece of a holiday table was the relish tray, full of pickles, celery, carrots, olives, nuts and fruit.
The offerings were inexpensive, relied on preserved foods and required no wheat, meat or sugar.
2. Maple syrup cake with maple icing
The cookbook noted American sugar consumption and encouraged home cooks to skip frostings and instead sweeten cakes with maple syrup, honey or molasses.
A maple syrup cake with maple icing was a festive, ration-friendly workaround.
3. Corn fritters
Corn fritters appear in the WWI cookbook as an example of a simple, wheat-saving side.
"Millions of people get along very well who never taste wheat.
It won't hurt us to do with less wheat," the book said.
Vogt said the recipe is still useful today: "If you come home from work one day, and you're like, 'I have nothing to cook,' you can pull that together in no time."
4. Buckwheat chocolate cake
Buckwheat, rye, cornmeal and oatmeal were promoted as alternatives to flour, and the WWI cookbook urged families to rethink how they baked.
The buckwheat chocolate cake offered a real treat while still honoring the conservation message, and Vogt has even made them as muffins: "I can genuinely attest … they're solid," she said.
5. Puritan turkey stuffing
The cookbook's Puritan stuffing didn't call for any actual turkey meat — only turkey fat.
Made from cornmeal, oatmeal, stale bread, chopped nuts and turkey drippings, the stuffing was designed to be economical and celebratory.
As Americans prepare to celebrate the nation's 250th year, the recipes offer a look back at a traditional holiday menu — one with plenty of elements that still feel familiar today, Vogt noted.
6. Meat: possum, tongue and mallard
During the WWI era, some meats were more practical, regional and even celebratory.
The cookbook included meats from chicken and turkey to venison, rabbit and squab, while some families served possum, tongue or wild duck.
Cookbooks from the early 1900s showed the "beautiful intersection of the fantastic tapestry that is America," reflected in the meats that appeared on holiday tables as families relied on regional and cultural traditions and made use of every part of the animal, Vogt said.
7. Plum pudding
The spirit of the Sugar Plum Fairy still found its way onto WWI tables, as plum pudding remained one of the era's most beloved Christmas desserts.
Households relied heavily on dried fruits like prunes, raisins and dates.
"While the ingredients and the making of the meal were important, it was about the memories that were made … who you were bringing around the table," Vogt said.
She added that American soldiers abroad were eating whatever was available overseas — sometimes even snails in Paris and donuts from Salvation Army tents, as one soldier wrote in letters preserved in the museum’s archives.
Deirdre Bardolf is a lifestyle writer with Fox News Digital.
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.