The Intercept81%
Would-Be Platner Replacements in Maine Rally Around “Abolish ICE” (or Something Close) 60%
By Noah Hurowitz79%
7/16/2026, 5:00:36 PM
BS Summary: This article contains 25 faulty reasoning types, including Biased Writer Voice, Recency Bias, and Availability Heuristic, with Negativity Bias as the most egregious example at 54.9% saturation with 417 hits. Analysis detected 2,017 faulty-reasoning hits from 760 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 56.1% and a BS Rank of 60% (6,802 of 16,769 articles). This article is worse (more manipulative) than 59.40% of the article peer group.
In the wake of a deadly shooting of a young father in southern Maine on Monday, the abbreviated race to replace Graham Platner on the Democratic Party ticket for the 2026 Senate race quickly became centered on immigration — and most of the serious contenders are on the same page.
At least five of the candidates to replace Platner have come out in favor of abolishing or “dismantling” U.S.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement after federal agents gunned down Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero in Biddeford, Maine.
The scramble to denounce ICE by would-be Democratic Senate nominees came days ahead of a scheduled debate on Thursday evening, where the hopefuls will face off to make the case for why they should take on incumbent Republican Sen.
Susan Collins.
Panagioti Tsolkas, a spokesperson for the Maine Immigrants’ Rights Coalition, said he was “heartened” to see the outpouring of anger from candidates in the wake of the shooting, but cautioned that a sustained effort would be needed from Maine’s politicians.
“We want to see the state of Maine step up right now and take action on a full investigation and accountability in this killing,” Tsolkas said.
“It’s gotta be more than lip service, and it has to be more than just showing up at the vigils when you have a chance to speak on stage.”
How ICE Arrests Went Quiet — and Got Even More Deadly
Durán Guerrero died early Monday morning after an ICE agent shot the 25-year-old during a traffic stop targeting another man, according to a spokesperson for the agency.
Durán Guerrero’s father told a news station in his native Colombia that his son was in the country legally, according to a report in the New York Times , and worked two jobs as a food delivery driver and cleaner at a veterinary clinic.
Durán Guerrero leaves behind a wife and 3-year-old daughter.
The killing sparked furious protests across the state and turned immigration enforcement into a centerpiece issue of Maine political chatter and the crowded mini-race, which kicked off last week and is set to culminate in a nominating convention in Bangor, Maine, on July 25.
Platner — who dropped out of the race last week after allegations emerged that he had sexually assaulted a former girlfriend, which he denies — had also called for ICE to be abolished.
In his July 10 letter removing himself from the race, he signed off by saying, “F*ck ICE.”
The unusual circumstances of Platner’s self-ejection from the race — despite the popularity of the movement that won him the primary in June — has set a curious political mood in Maine.
Candidates seeking to replace him are hewing to his message while differentiating themselves from his scandal-plagued personal brand.
With just days left to make their pitch to Mainers, many of the candidates to replace Platner veered toward the nearest solidarity rally or anti-ICE protest as news of the killing filtered out of Biddeford.
Maine Senate Candidates Claim They’re Just Like Platner — But Entirely Different
The candidates calling for ICE to be abolished include Troy Jackson, a progressive from northern Maine who’s swept up a raft of endorsements from local politicians and labor groups despite an underwhelming showing in the recent gubernatorial primary; fellow gubernatorial also-ran Dr.
Nirav Shah; social worker Paige Loud and former political operative and fundraiser Jordan Wood , both of whom ran in the Democratic primary for Maine’s 2nd Congressional District; and Dan Kleban , the founder of a beer company in Maine who threw his hat into the ring for the Senate race last week.
While most Democrats in Maine have been highly critical of ICE and President Donald Trump’s mass deportation agenda — especially in the wake of a surge of federal agents to the state in January — only Jackson and Loud appear to have called for the agency to be abolished prior to Monday’s shooting.
With a majority of the candidates now declaring a full-throated commitment to scrapping ICE altogether, this week marked a sharp leftward shift in immigration discourse in Maine in the wake of Durán Guerrero’s killing.
Other candidates, while sharply criticizing ICE for the killing of Durán Guerrero, stopped short of calling for the agency to be abolished.
Shenna Bellows, the current Maine secretary of state, spoke in Biddeford about having denied Border Patrol the use of undercover license plates in the state during the surge earlier this year.
On X, she employed the slogan “ICE off our streets.”
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.