Faulty reasoning signals

• Biased Writer Voice - 33.8%
• Framing Effect - 23.6%
• False Dilemma - 22%

Article text

Normally, we’d already be finished talking about Graham Platner . The Democratic nominee for Senate in Maine would have dropped out within a day of being credibly accused of rape and losing establishment and progressive support across the board. Former backers called the accusations against him “troubling,” “deeply serious” and “damning” as they raced to withdraw their endorsements . (He has denied the allegations.) The two days since the most serious allegations broke have been filled with nasty exchanges between state party leaders and Platner, as well as speculation about when he’ll step aside and who will take his place on the ticket. Regardless of who that is, how the Maine Democratic Party replaces him seems likely to be just as important to winning the race for a party clinging to hope of flipping the Senate. The state party can be forgiven for not having a plan ready to go. While there is a law that designates timing for replacing a statewide candidate, party leaders have indicated there was no established internal process for it. But it’s possible whatever process they settle on to choose the next candidate will become a proxy fight for the questions around establishment politics and transparency. On an all-hands call Wednesday evening, Maine Democratic Party Chair Charlie Dingman told state committee members that party leaders want to hold a nominating convention, two members on the call told MS NOW. Under Dingman’s proposal, county committees would convene this weekend to choose a total of 500-600 delegates, according to the people on the call, who spoke on condition of anonymity. Later, the party put out a statement signed by Dingman and two other party leaders saying the roughly 100 members on the call had voted in favor of a convention. It did not include any other details about how that will work, including a date or location. State law would give the party until July 27 to put forward Platner’s replacement. The party leadership’s statement included an olive branch of sorts to Platner’s camp: “There is an unprecedented amount of energy and enthusiasm among Maine Democrats, driven in part by many of the dedicated volunteers and supporters who were inspired by Graham Platner’s campaign,” it read. “We look forward to coming together and harnessing that energy around our new nominee as we work to defeat Susan Collins.” That a spotlight has fallen on Maine is no surprise. This Senate race is critical, if not potentially definitive, when it comes to whether Democrats have a realistic chance at retaking the Senate from Republicans in the fall. Collins, the Republican incumbent, has won this seat repeatedly since her first victory in 1996. Democrats’ effort to defeat her in 2020 amounted to an electoral embarrassment for the party at large, given the presidential headwinds and amount of time and attention trained on seeing Collins lose. The thing is, making this about trying to prevent the establishment from just deciding who the next candidate is doubles as an example of what candidates like Platner were and are running against and is already part of the overall midterm conversation. That’s thanks in no small part to the unsuccessful late-stage swap of former Vice President Kamala Harris for former President Joe Biden in the 2024 presidential election. Whatever moves the state party makes, it’s already within the frame of a major political primary story: progressives versus establishment and whether the Democratic Party listens to all types of Americans. Maine Democrats’ process could end up being a new litmus test for candidates outside the state, who could get asked if they agree with it as a stand-in question for whether they’re with the progressive movement or against it. “The Maine Democratic Party should make clear this morning what the process will be,” Progressive Change Campaign Committee co-founder Adam Green told CBS News before the party’s meeting Wednesday. “Will their quote-unquote ‘open and transparent process’ be a couple hundred Democratic Party insiders in a convention room deciding who the nominee is? Or will there be a caucus site in every county where every Democratic voter can vote?” Making that the fight — how Democrats collectively decide to choose Platner’s replacement — instead of focusing on who can beat Collins could quickly create the best climate for her to get re-elected. “If he’s dropping out,” Democratic voter Janice Sears told MS NOW in Portland, “let’s rally together and find somebody who can beat Susan Collins.” Will McDuffie, Hunter Woodall and Kevin Frey contributed. The post For Democrats replacing Platner, the how will be as big as the who appeared first on MS NOW .