Faulty reasoning signals

• Biased Writer Voice - 66.7%
• Availability Heuristic - 19.7%
• Halo Effect - 18.7%

Article text

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

You’ve got to hand it to whichever lawyers wrote the NDAs for guests of Taylor Swift’s wedding. It’s been five days since she took over Madison Square Garden and blocked off a sizable slice of midtown Manhattan for her July 3 nuptials , and no major details have yet emerged about the pop superstar’s dress.

But we do know who designed it. Jonathan Anderson got the commission, a major score for a creative director who was brought to Dior a little over a year ago with the task of amping up the brand’s global profile. The newly wedded couple must have gotten a bundle deal: Travis Kelce opted for bespoke Christian Dior, too, and both stars wore custom Christian Louboutin shoes.

In her wardrobe and her music, Swift tends to slot herself into a variety of classic feminine roles: the fairy-tale princess, the high school lover girl, America’s sweetheart. Before her wedding, fashion writers predicted a slew of designers whose wedding gowns might fit those archetypes. Ralph Lauren, one of whose dresses Swift wore for her enchanted-garden engagement shoot , would have been a solid choice for a “ Miss Americana ” getting hitched on Independence Day weekend. Vivienne Westwood, she of the Swift-approved corset-and-draped-skirt combo, would have made a garment worthy of the dewy-eyed romance and grandiosity Swift brings to her love songs.

Dior was not among the most buzzed-about contenders; Vogue didn’t even name it in its top five guesses . Swift has barely worn the brand—though she’s been spotted carrying a variety of Dior handbags this spring—which makes her choice of Anderson a bit of a surprise. For a celebrity who, for better and for worse, has placed her own personal tastes above fast-changing trends and the cachet of high fashion, picking a big-name designer at an illustrious French house to make her gown signals a desire to project a new degree of fashion prestige.

The former creative director at Loewe and the founder of his own JW Anderson label, Anderson has made his name with designs that add a contemporary edge to classic styles. He is fluent in preppy, attracted to whimsy, and adept at mining womenswear for menswear ideas (and vice versa). He’s made approachable, mass-market lines with Topshop and Uniqlo, and his versatile talents have led to a creative partnership with director Luca Guadagnino, for whom he led costume design for the buzzy films Challengers and Queer . In December, the Fashion Awards in the U.K. named him Designer of the Year for the third consecutive year.

As a choice of wedding dress designer, Anderson at Dior represents both a rising star and an established powerhouse, a forward-looking vision backed by timeless tradition. No one would have expected Taylor Swift, who never met a sequin she didn’t like, to tap an overly hip or outré designer for her nuptials, but as far as picks that could have reasonably landed in the Swiftiverse, this one is objectively somewhat cool.

But what about the actual dress, which still exists as a mere wisp of imagination for those of us who weren’t at the arena wedding? Though a statement from Swift’s camp trumpets her gown as Anderson’s “first couture wedding dress for a world-renowned celebrity,” the designer has dressed a few other high-profile brides in Dior Haute Couture. At her wedding last month, Chinese supermodel Ming Xi wore a clean-lined, just-off-the-shoulder gown with long, buttoned sleeves. Shortly after, Brazilian influencer Elisa Zarzur got married in a dress with a beaded top that extended around her back into two long lace panels that laid atop a full satin skirt. Both gowns featured structured panels that stood open like flower petals, framing Ming’s back and Zarzur’s neck, a display of Anderson’s penchant for organic shapes, leaf-like layers, and just-south-of-ordinary silhouettes.

It seems inevitable, though, that Swift would want something unlike any of Anderson’s previous bridal creations, something befitting the superlative American royalty she envisions herself to be. It may fit comfortably within the bounds of her own style, which leans into romance, playful femininity, and the occasional whiff of drama. Or it may be a departure from her brand, marking a new era of risk-taking in the realm of personal taste as her love life enters a phase of seeming stability. Anderson has the range to execute either vision.

Unlike his wife, Kelce has an outlandish streak , with a history of head-turning—and occasionally head-scratching—outfits. On Monday, when Anderson showcased his newest Dior couture collection in Paris, I couldn’t help but fantasize about the footballer arriving at the altar in some of those sculptural metallic pleats , or maybe a pair of maximalist, charm-covered loafers. But Kelce usually saves his grandest fashion statements for his solo tunnel walks; with Swift, her star power often steers the look. This is a guy who wore shorts for their engagement pictures so they could both be dressed in Ralph Lauren. It’s probably too big a wedding wish for his tux to upstage the bride.

Slate relies on advertising to support our journalism. If you value our

work, please disable your ad blocker. If you want to block ads but still

support Slate, consider subscribing.